Pi Pizzeria

Your go-to spot for wood-fired ‘za

By Catherine Smart

Sometimes you just need to get away from it all and dig into an excellent pie. This super-casual, mid-island pizza and pasta joint (with ample parking!) is the place to do it. They’ve got wood-fired Neapolitan-style pizzas ranging from traditional Margherita and New England classic White Clam, to our favorite: the Rustica, with stracchino cheese, pancetta, garlic, and a fresh arugula topping that’s piled on after it comes out of the brick oven. Order a glass of prosecco and chat with the bartender, or get takeout and bring your Italian feast to the beach.

Pi Pizzeria

11 West Creek Road, Nantucket, MA

  • Must Have


When your pizza has rich stracchino cheese, pancetta, and garlic on crisp crust—all under a mountain of fresh arugula—you won’t be missing the red sauce.

  • Insider Tip

The takeout/deli area is the place to stock your pantry with chocolates, dried pasta, olive oils, meats, cheeses and other specialty foods.

Subscribe to our newsletter!

Sign up for our weekly newsletters for curated guides, can't-miss dishes, restaurant recommendations, and more.

Enter Email